In 1863 the Confederate House of
Representatives
ordered an investigation into the
conduct of the
commandant, Captain
George W. Alexander. He was accused of
"harshness,
inhumanity, tyranny, and dishonesty."
Alexander was
eventually
cleared of the charges, partially by
citing the
hard-bitten character of the inmates as
justification for his behavior.
Alexander thought the most difficult
prisoners were
the "pug-uglies of Baltimore and the
wharf-rats of
New Orleans." But
not just the commandant thought Castle
Thunder
residents to especially tough, the
prisoners
themselves reveled in their
fearsome reputation.
After Richmond fell in 1865, Union
troops continued
to use Castle Thunder to house
Confederates accused
of war crimes.
A converted tobacco warehouse, Castle
Thunder
was widely regarded as an especially
rigorous
lockup. Used to house
political prisoners, spies, and
criminals charge
with treason, it was considered to be a
fearsome
place even by
Southerners. Even though the inmates
were sometimes
allowed boxes of medicine and other
supplies, the
prison guards
had a reputation for brutality.